By: Brittany Downey

Is Social Media Worth It for Small Businesses? (Even the “Boring” Ones): A Conversation with Chase Pickett

Chase Pickett is co-founder and CEO of Precision Social, a Chicago-based social media marketing agency that helps businesses build trust and grow through organic and paid social.

This is an abridged version of our conversation. Listen to the full episode right here, or find it on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.


Why did you go all in on organic social?

It’s not often a highly regarded role. A lot of people delegate that down to whoever’s youngest.

However, I believe organic social is the best testing environment right now for any form of marketing you could ever put out there. One of the main reasons I believe that is it’s free. Yes, you have to pay someone to create the content, but in any other marketing context you also have to pay someone for the distribution. If you want to put your thing on a billboard, in a newspaper, on a commercial, you have to pay for that. On organic social you don’t.

And it’s never been available that way in history. My grandfather ran a tire shop. I can only imagine he would be shaking me by the shoulders, like, “Why aren’t you posting every day? I didn’t even have that opportunity. I was knocking on doors and shaking hands and going to community events.” He had to do a lot more physical grassroots stuff to reach a smaller number of people, where I can make a video, post it from my bed, and reach a couple thousand.


Where does community fit into that?

We believe community building is the most sustainable way to market your business. Building depth in addition to width. Width being the number of people you reach, depth being how deeply you reach them, how much you impact their emotional center. It’s harder to lose customers that way. You build actual relationships at scale.

Social is two-way, it’s interactive. It’s different than SMS marketing or a billboard campaign or an email campaign. But we believe community building is the best way to immunize your business, whether it’s COVID or a competitor. People are emotionally attached to your business at this point, because you put in the work to get there.


Most brands set their messaging first and layer social on top. You do it in reverse?

We do social first, and I’ll point right back to the testing grounds.

Hypothetically, we could put out fifteen to thirty pieces of content in any given month for any given brand and test five or seven different messaging angles, and by day fifteen, day twenty, day thirty we have a really good understanding of which messaging angle is resonating. It’s not even debatable. It’s numbers.

These algorithms by Meta and TikTok have figured out how to serve content to people in the way that’s most relevant to them. If I post something and it gets five hundred views, and the next day I post something and it gets fifteen hundred views, I don’t have to debate what resonated more.

The other thing is the speed. Real-time data capture, and within weeks, not months, you can have a really good understanding of what messaging you want to lean into. The message is the foundation. It’s on your merchandise, it’s on your sales flyer, it’s on everything. These are insights we can get organically.

Brittany: What a better way to decide what to focus on in your messaging, rather than sitting around the boardroom with everybody throwing out ideas. “Well, I like this.” “Well, I don’t like this.” You actually have something concrete to point back to instead of your own opinion, and it can be so easy to drive things off of your own opinion.

Chase: Absolutely. We have a phrase we bring up all the time: consumer first, boardroom second. And we bring that to our clients. “Hey, Mr. and Mrs. Customer, there will be a time where you want us to push a certain angle or creative or message, and we’re going to push against that.” Consumer first, boardroom second.


What do you need in place before you start posting?

Social media is for everybody. I’ve seen people of all shapes and sizes crush on social media, whether they were completely digitally incompetent and over the age of seventy, or twenty-two and grew up with an iPhone in their hand.

I would like to advocate for simply doing it, because what you’ll learn by posting will trump anything you could ponder and think about.

iPhone and tripod is literally all you need. If you want to get crazy, you can get a ninety dollar wireless microphone. So for an iPhone you probably already have and less than two hundred dollars of tripod and microphone, you can get off to the races. I genuinely believe it is not as complicated as we make it out to be.


How do you find content ideas for a business most people would call boring?

In the early years it was a mountain for us to climb, both executionally and culturally. It was hard to get my teammates excited about working on the window washing client or the HVAC client.

Boring to you and I is not boring to everyone else.

If you make content about window washing, you can bank on that reaching homeowners, because the algorithm’s not dumb. I’m not a homeowner. I’ve never got my windows washed, and it’s not in my imminent future, but it might be in ten years.

I’m a big fan of documenting over creating. If you just document your process, people are interested in them. I’ve seen cafes talk about their revenue numbers: “We sold this many cups of coffee.” People seem very interested in that, and then they have something to root for.

If you are the founder of a window washing company, showing what your day-to-day is like is actually valuable to people. There’s always a story to be found, and that’s something we focus on trying to extract out of people.


What’s the biggest thing keeping founders from getting on camera?

Most of the time they undersell themselves and their story. They think that what they do and say and know and learned over the last ten, twenty years isn’t as valuable as it is.

It’s a huge generational gap. A guy or gal who started a business in 1995 and still runs it today probably didn’t see this coming. “Thirty years into my business, but I’m still ten years out from retirement, and now everyone’s telling me I’ve got to get on camera.” I have a lot of empathy for why that feels foreign.

Sometimes people are genuinely humble and don’t want to “exalt” themselves. I don’t think it’s what people think it is. We want to get the authentic feeling out of you and out to the world.

I started a second business, and it’s in home services. You can imagine how I’m running that. My face is all over it. My business partner’s face is all over it. We’re posting all the time. We’re posting things that maybe a normal company wouldn’t, and we don’t have to go through these approvals because this is where my belief is.

So hopefully this becomes a case study that can show people, “Hey, I went head first on it. This is what I believe. Here’s the results. I would love to do the same for you.”


What does someone have to believe for social to work for them?

They have to believe that it is long-term valuable to them. If they are expecting a short-term, 90-day, even 180-day immediate gain and justification, I’d say don’t start, genuinely, until you cross the barrier mentally of “this is the right decision for my business” in a five, ten, and twenty year window.

I’ve watched people in my personal life spend six to twelve months creating content hard, intentionally, and nothing happened. But then something did, and everything changed after that.


How do you get from engagement to business results?

The most tactical and direct answer is taking your insights and content from organic social and moving them to paid social. If you’re seeing any amount of progress in views, likes, comments, shares, and saves, the meaningful metrics on social media, and you want to see business results from that, the quickest and most direct way is to take that exact piece of content that’s overperforming and move it into Meta ads and TikTok ads.

If you posted twenty times last month and the average post is getting a thousand views, but these three posts got ten thousand views, or even five thousand views, put that in perspective. That’s five times the number of views as normal. Clearly something’s going right with those pieces of content.

Sometimes you have to re-edit it. If my most popular post last month was a trend of me dancing, how is that going to help me sell more shirts? Well, it might not, but I can change the text on screen, or include a closer part to that video. Keep the bones of the video that performed well and add a little bit more sales aggression and call to action toward the end. Now run that as an ad.

I believe you’ve effectively mitigated the risk of spending wasted ad spend on something that’s not going to work, and you already know it’s going to resonate with people. This time it’s attached to an offer. “Twenty percent off,” “buy before Labor Day,” whatever it may be.


How can businesses cut down on the overwhelm of social media?

It is easy to be plagued by the complexity and volume of what we think we should be producing. If it’s any solace to anyone, there are a million different ways to win, and you don’t have to do all of them. You don’t even have to do some of them. You just have to do one to three of them. It’s beneficial to understand that we don’t have to be making the same sort of content as so-and-so just because they’re in the same niche or same vertical.

The most direct and tactical answer in the here and now is content series. Those are dominating social media right now. “Day one of this” is the most basic example. They’re not always day-based, but you’ll see recurring series that are maybe three videos, five videos. I’ve seen upwards of one hundred, two hundred videos in one series that people want to follow along with.

A content series or two is a great idea because it gives you a framework. I’ll point to the garage cleanup business. We find a lot of interesting items in people’s garages, and we film the whole process. An example of a series we might play with is “item of the week,” or “here are three different items this week” that were wacky enough to talk about on video. Not in a rude way, more in an amusing way. “I can’t believe I found this in someone’s garage and they had it for this long. This is such a rare item.” Can we add some personality to that? We may run three or five of those videos and we may learn that’s not resonating, and that’s okay. We’ll move on to another content series. But a content series gives you the framework to say, “I could do this week in, week out.”

Brittany: I love that. It follows a principle I like: decide once. Instead of deciding over and over, you decide one time. For my family’s gifts this year, I decided everyone gets a special book, so all I have to think about is which book. A content series works the same way. You decide once on the content you’ll make multiple times to test, instead of figuring it out from scratch each time.

Chase: Man, I love that. I’ve got to write that on a post-it note and keep it on my desk. Decide once.


How do you define growth, for yourself and for the business?

My walk with God is first and foremost. How am I doing is how am I walking with God. My relationship with my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ is how I measure my growth. That’s new for me as of a couple of years ago. I didn’t always measure my growth that way. I measured it much more financially and transactionally, and I found that that didn’t lead very far.

It’s helped me have much better perspective on my business. My value personally is not tied to the business anymore like it used to be, and I can look at it more clearly and objectively. It has not taken away from my commitment to growing Precision Social. My hair’s not on fire anymore about the issues that arise.

We’re at eleven people or so, so I am in a maturation phase. I’ve matured to the point where I understand what numbers I’m looking for, what kind of revenue numbers and gross profit margins. What it costs to acquire a client, what it costs to let a client go after six months versus two and a half years.

And our big goal is literally to change the perspective on marketing. The transactional nature is on the way out, and we’re in the age of information. Buyers in the B2B space have the ability to research you, and they will, before they speak to you. So hopefully you’ve created an environment that is warm and inviting and educational and valuable and entertaining to them.

A lot of times they come to us with, “Okay, I’m going to spend five grand with you in May. What did I get out of that in June?” If I can see someone go from that to, “Hey Chase, I want to invest more money and make this really big campaign,” and they don’t have an attachment to the ninety-day financial window, that’s when I know they’ve crossed the threshold and they see the value of it in a two, five, ten year context.


Listen to the full conversation with Chase Pickett wherever you get your podcasts.

Chase’s LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/chase-pickett-social
Precision Social: precisionsocial.com